Fancy Nancy Country Store

Nancy Lewis, Founder of Fancy Nancy Country Store

Nancy Lewis, Founder of Fancy Nancy Country Store


Welcome to Fancy Nancy Country Store of Sayville, New York.  Our mission is to provide our customers that authentic old-fashioned country store experience, while also offering them a one-stop shop where they can purchase products from local Long Island and New York State vendors and producers.  Nancy herself is registered with the New York State Farm Bureau.

Come by and visit our relaxing space and shop for everything from farm fresh local produce, eggs, milk and butter and all kinds of items produced by local farmers market vendors, such as home-jarred products, home baked goods, beef jerky, doggie treats, locally made snacks, pickles, coffee, local honey, and so much more.

Or maybe you are looking for a one-of-a-kind gift or item for your own home. Choose from a wide variety of local artisans, like their hand-knitted items, bags, glass sculptures, pillows, baby clothes, signs, candles and a wide variety of other pieces.

Our featured products remain Fancy Nancy soaps and lotions, all handcrafted since 2011,  all natural, made from scratch, and chock full of authentic, nourishing ingredients. Also featured are countless flavors of jams, preserves, mustards, and pickled fruits and veggies (try the figs!), all made in house. Plus a rotating daily menu of soups, quiches, chili and other comfort foods, also made in house.

Come visit the proprietors, Nancy and Ian Lewis, long-time Oakdale neighbors and friends.  If the lights are on, they are there, ready to welcome you to their home away from home. So pull up a stool or relax in one of our rocking chairs and step into a comforting reminder of days gone by.